==+== FAST '09 Paper Review Form ==-== Set the paper number and fill out lettered sections A through G. ==-== DO NOT CHANGE LINES THAT START WITH “==+==”! ==-== A single file can contain multiple forms. ==-== For further guidance, or to upload this file when you are done, go to: ==-== https://papers.usenix.org/hotcrp/fast09/offline
+==
==+== Begin Review
==+== Paper #000000 ==-== Replace '000000' with the actual paper number.
==+== Review Readiness ==-== Enter “Ready” here if the review is ready for others to see:
Ready
==+== A. Overall merit ==-== Enter a number from 1 to 5. ==-== Choices: 1. Reject ==-== 2. Weak reject ==-== 3. Weak accept ==-== 4. Accept ==-== 5. Strong accept
==+== B. Novelty ==-== Enter a number from 1 to 5. ==-== Choices: 1. Published before ==-== 2. Done before (not necessarily published) ==-== 3. Incremental improvement ==-== 4. New contribution ==-== 5. Surprisingly new contribution
==+== C. Longevity ==-== How important will this work be over time? ==-== Enter a number from 1 to 5. ==-== Choices: 1. Not important now or later ==-== 2. Low importance ==-== 3. Average importance ==-== 4. Important ==-== 5. Exciting
==+== D. Reviewer expertise ==-== Enter a number from 1 to 4. ==-== Choices: 1. No familiarity ==-== 2. Some familiarity ==-== 3. Knowledgeable ==-== 4. Expert
==+== E. Paper summary
==+== F. Comments for author
==+== G. Comments for PC (hidden from authors)
==+== End Review