Systems Research Laboratory

This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.
==+== FAST '09 Paper Review Form

==-== Set the paper number and fill out lettered sections A through G.

==-== DO NOT CHANGE LINES THAT START WITH "==+=="!

==+== RAJU MUST REPLACE THIS LINE BEFORE UPLOADING

==+== Begin Review

==+== Paper #000000

==-== Replace '000000' with the actual paper number.



==+== Review Readiness

==-== Enter "Ready" here if the review is ready for others to see:

[Enter your choice here]



==+== A. Overall merit

==-== Enter a number from 1 to 5.

==-== Choices: 1. Reject

==-==          2. Weak reject

==-==          3. Weak accept

==-==          4. Accept

==-==          5. Strong accept


[Enter your choice here]


==+== B. Novelty

==-== Enter a number from 1 to 5.

==-== Choices: 1. Published before

==-==          2. Done before (not necessarily published)

==-==          3. Incremental improvement

==-==          4. New contribution

==-==          5. Surprisingly new contribution


[Enter your choice here]


==+== C. Longevity

==-==    How important will this work be over time?

==-== Enter a number from 1 to 5.

==-== Choices: 1. Not important now or later

==-==          2. Low importance

==-==          3. Average importance

==-==          4. Important

==-==          5. Exciting


[Enter your choice here]


==+== D. Reviewer expertise

==-== Enter a number from 1 to 4.

==-== Choices: 1. No familiarity

==-==          2. Some familiarity

==-==          3. Knowledgeable

==-==          4. Expert


[Enter your choice here]


==+== E. Paper summary


[Enter your comments here]


==+== F. Comments for author


[Enter your comments here]


==+== G. Comments for PC (hidden from authors)


[Enter your comments here]


==+== End Review